“Cultural sovereignty refers to the right of a nation or community to preserve, develop, and govern its own culture and identity without external domination. It extends the traditional idea of state sovereignty beyond territory, law, and politics into the realm of values, language, art, religion, and ways of living. A state may control its borders perfectly well yet still find its citizens absorbing foreign values through screens and digital platforms that no checkpoint can stop” (PolSci Institute).
This statement rings all the more true in the context of information and communication ecosystems, where checkpoints (effective oversight and regulation) are few and far between. And cultural sovereignty today is increasingly being held to ransom by technological globalization (motivated by the endless drive for profits), together with the continued political and economic subversion of the Majority World by the Minority World. The recent furore over Artificial Intelligence (AI) is fuelled in part by its autocratic potential for domination and control of peoples and markets, and its exponential capacity for grabbing data.
Fortunately, digital technologies and AI can be used to fight back, provided that communities and nations are able to innovate and deploy them on their own terms. Such a form of governance could upset the applecarts of Big Tech by establishing local communication ecosystems that are independent and culturally embedded. As Kersti Ruth Wissenbach argues in her article in this issue of Media Development:
“Communities must be authors, builders, and decisionmakers of the systems that carry their voices, not passive recipients of systems designed for them by others. Cultural integrity, understood as the capacity of communities to sustain and develop their own cultural forms, languages, and knowledge systems, is not an aspiration to be added onto digital inclusion strategies but constitutes the precondition of genuine communication justice, and therefore of genuine digital justice.”
Much work has been carried out in Nigeria, Mexico, Indonesia and elsewhere to promote community-centred connectivity as well as contributing to an enabling ecosystem for its emergence and growth. In this regard, local governance is crucial as Waqar Rizvi underlines in his article in this issue of Media Development. He identifies five questions that would help distinguish community governance from mere community-facing language (paying lip service to the notion) and thus strengthen cultural sovereignty:
“Who sets the priorities tells us where a project begins. Who owns it tells us what remains when a donor or contractor leaves. Where decision-making authority sits tells us who can change course. External dependencies show where that authority may still be constrained. Accountability tells us whether the people holding power, international or local, can themselves be challenged.”
At the heart of this debate lies the notion that communication rights are an essential and integral part of both digital justice and equitable social progress. Some commentators seem not to understand this or, if they do, to cloud the issue with all kinds of caveats. Yet, communication justice demands democratic equality; it demands the removal of historical bias and cultural dominance; it demands respect for the human dignity of all peoples everywhere.
It is worth recalling the 1980 MacBride Report, officially titled Many Voices, One World and commissioned by UNESCO to analyze global communication problems and media imbalances between developed and developing nations. In relation to cultural sovereignty, the report’s concerns and recommendations – transferred to today’s digitalization of societies – remain pertinent:
“Cultural identity is endangered by the overpowering influence on and assimilation of some national cultures though these nations may well be the heirs to more ancient and richer cultures… [I]t will often be necessary to protect and strengthen the threatened culture, develop communication at a local level, and open up alternative forms of communication as an antidote to the pressure of the big media. It should be stressed, too, that the problem does not arise solely in the relationships between one nation and another; often, it takes its sharpest form and presents the most pressing dangers within nations whose population includes cultural minorities” (p. 31).
Shaping a democratic digital future demands the kind of cultural sovereignty that allows the preservation, development, and government of communities’ own cultures and identities in parity with others and without external domination. As Agostina Coniglio states in her article in this issue of Media Development:
“From this perspective, cultural integrity acquires a vital dimension of agency. Beyond preserving traditions, knowledge, or identities in the face of digitization, we must retain and exercise the capacity for self-determination throughout the process itself. This means acting as authors of our own digital transformation – not merely taking part in it, but retaining the leverage to shape its trajectory. Ultimately, we must ask ourselves, what kind of data-relational society do we truly want to build? One that expands the exercise of our rights into the digital realm, or one that ends up restricting and conditioning them?”