What kind of data-relational society do we want to build?
69122
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-69122,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,wp-child-theme-WACC-bridge,bridge-core-3.3.5,qodef-qi--no-touch,qi-addons-for-elementor-1.11.2,qode-page-transition-enabled,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,qode-smooth-scroll-enabled,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-30.9.1,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,qode-wpml-enabled,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-9.0.1,vc_responsive,elementor-default,elementor-kit-41156

What kind of data-relational society do we want to build?

Agostina Coniglio

Imagine living in a country where 99% of public services are digitized. Today, most would view this as major technological achievement – or simply as the natural trajectory of a hyper-connected world. Global data suggest we are rapidly moving in this direction; in 2025, roughly 74% of the world’s population (over 6 billion people) were online. Yet, the metrics we traditionally use to evaluate digital inclusion tell a far more complex story.

Technology has undoubtedly streamlined and enhanced daily life. We typically frame the quantification of human experience around convenience and utility. While valid, this narrative remains incomplete – it obscures the inherent risks, systemic limits, and less visible trade-offs embedded within these technologies.

Datafication begins with the information we voluntarily share, but it rapidly reaches the most private corners of daily life. Year after year, the volume of generated data expands exponentially, feeding sophisticated systems that primarily yield value for external actors. The adage “data is the new oil” overlooks a critical prerequisite. For data to exist as a resource, human life must first be extracted and converted into data points.

What is striking is how unremarkable this continuous conversion has become. Is the datafication of people a social phenomenon that we have simply ended up naturalizing?

Access to digital environments is traditionally equated with the opportunity to enjoy their benefits, assuming that greater technological deployment automatically fosters greater inclusion. However, viewing digital inequality strictly through the lens of the digital divide creates a misleading narrative; since it assumes that the mere absence of technology is the only driver of inequality. Reality is far more nuanced.

Exclusion, inclusion, and what comes next?

Across the Global South, physical access gaps persist, yet they alone no longer explain why inequality endures despite rising connectivity rates. According to data form ECLAC’s Digital Development Observatory, while network expansion has brought most of the region online, severe disparities remain in connectivity quality, speed, and affordability – the essential prerequisites for meaningful socio-economic advancement. Consequently, the widespread adoption of smart devices and infrastructure has narrowed the physical access gap without eroding structural inequality or long -standing development divides.

The binary logic of inclusion versus exclusion fails to capture the complex power dynamics generated within digital ecosystems. The debate must shift from whether people access technology to the structural conditions governing that access – and our agency to shape them. While exclusion asks who participates, the concept of adverse digital incorporation compels us to question how they participate. This shifts the focus toward relational dynamics. That is to say an individual’s position within the digital ecosystem; who captures the extracted value; and who ultimately bear the risks, costs, and systemic harms.

To address the root causes of inequality, digital justice must examine not only the outcomes of digital participation, but also the relational structures and decision-making power that generate them. Under what conditions does inclusion take place, and what renders those conditions equitable?

To unpack these dynamics, I propose the following framework.

A four-dimensional and interconnected framework:

1. Access

Contemporary perspectives agree that access alone is not enough to talk about digital inclusion. The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) formalized this shift through the concept of meaningful connectivity, encompassing six dimensions: quality, availability, affordability, devices, skills and safety.

Consider again a society where 99% public services are digitized. Even assuming universal access to devices, reliable connectivity and digital skills, can we guarantee that individuals engage on equal terms or achieve equitable outcomes? As digital participation becomes mandatory for accessing essential services and civic life, framing this inclusion as entirely “voluntary” becomes untenable.

Addressing this requires moving beyond a linear understanding of digital inequality. Rather than merely reflecting offline divides, pre-existing inequalities actively shape how individuals enter and navigate digital spaces. Conversely, the specific features of these technologies allow digital interactions to reinforce physical realities, amplifying existing disparities and giving rise to new ones.

If the relationship between technology and inequality is circular, digital inequality cannot be understood merely as a byproduct of exclusion. If this is the case; is meaningful access on its own, ever sufficient to guarantee just and equitable terms of inclusion?

2. Representation

Representation in digital spaces fundamentally addresses whether people are visible and how adequately they are recognized. While visibility is essential, digital engagement increasingly translates our existence into data – quantified into categories and profiles that dictate how we are perceived and treated. Who holds the authority to define these terms?

Under this framework, it would be a mistake to assume that greater digital visibility automatically ensures fair representation. The second dimension of this model highlights a core tension between having visibility and exercising control over it. A marginalized community may be excluded from datasets and rendered invisible; conversely, another group may be hyper-visible yet framed entirely through categories imposed by third parties. How can we determine if these representation terms are fair?

Data is never a neutral reflection of the physical world. Retaining control over one’s own visibility – as well as participating in the design and logic of the technologies capturing it – is equally critical. Data is always about something or someone, and the decisions embedded in its design reflect specific worldviews. If complex social realities can be reduced to automated solutions, we risk treating people as mere objects withing digital systems, rather than recognizing them as agents capable of shaping their own representation.

Paradoxically, while privacy and data protection regulations remain essential, they fail to address the broader engineering driving datafication. Much of this infrastructure operates invisibly and horizontally – spanning public and private entities – and relies on data that can be manipulated in countless ways. Furthermore, digital tools are often framed as objective simple because automated systems apply uniform rules to everyone. However, this does not guarantee non-discriminatory outcomes if the underlying categories, datasets or assumptions mirror structural pre-existing inequalities.

When digitally generated categories inform real-world decision-making, they risk perpetuating and amplifying historical stereotypes. From this standpoint, cultural integrity involves more than just preserving heritage or identity against digitization; it requires retaining agency and self-determination throughout the digitization process itself. The question is: whose values, knowledge, and worldviews are ultimately shaping digital identity?

3. Power Relations

The third-dimension frames digital systems as sets of power relationships embedded within technology – relationships driven by data extraction and the decisions governing its use.

If data is neither abstract nor neutral, and if the infrastructures designed to extract and re-purpose it serves those who fund, own and design them, then datafication lies at the intersection of power, knowledge and social organization.

At the same time, an increasing reliance on data blurs lines of accountability and transparency. When users grant digital consent, it creates an illusion of personal autonomy. The seamless nature of modern technology makes participation feel like an independent choice, even when the underlying terms are predetermined. When we are unaware of these structural conditions – or acutely aware that they cannot change them – how much autonomy does our decision truly carry in the end?

We may doubt whether the choices we make in the digital realm truly define us. In fact, taking social quantification for granted risks legitimizing asymmetric power structures without considering broader consequences. Hierarchical dynamics in digital spaces stem directly from these structural imbalances. Not all actors share equal access to data and the benefits derived from it, and lack equal literacy regarding how it is collected, processed, and used. Crucially, they lack equal leverage to negotiate the terms of their digital engagement.

Digital inequality goes beyond access; it concerns where communities can translate data into actionable knowledge, capture its value, and exercise decision-making power over it. Therefore, digital rights cannot be confined to individual privacy and data protection. What is our  position withing these systems?

We are at once the producers of this “new oil”, its users, its consumers, and eventually we become part of it. In this scenario, how much of the value we help generate can we actually capture or govern? Being consulted users or consenting data generators is not necessarily equivalent to exercising authority over the ends and benefits of datafication.

These power asymmetries become evident when the benefits, risks and consequences of datafication are distributed unequally— often becoming more pronounced when they intersect with pre-existing vulnerabilities to impact the most marginalized communities. How, then, is the power to set the terms of digital participation distributed and exercised?

4. Agency

The authorship of our own digital experience becomes questionable when the terms governing it are defined by actors whose capabilities vastly exceed our own. That raises a fundamental question. What real agency do we possess to influence these conditions?

Communication rights offer a robust human rights framework to address this question through the lens of digital justice. This perspective is grounded in the interconnected exercise of established fundamental rights – including freedom of expression, access to information, civic participation, and privacy, alongside cultural rights. For some communities, this framework extends to specific rights tied to self-determination, cultural heritage and prior informed consultation. Participation in digital spaces should therefore unfold under conditions that guarantee the effective exercise of these rights.

Nonetheless, participating does not necessarily imply having authority, just as having a voice does not automatically translate into exercising influence. Thus, while communication rights provide a critical framework for evaluating digital inclusion, a central question remains. What capacity do we actually have to exercise these rights and meaningfully shape the terms of our participation? Does inclusion in digital environments equate to genuine influence over their design and governance?

True agency requires the capacity to make decision, express needs and perspectives, questioning existing terms and actively impact structural outcomes. Mere consultation regarding pre-established terms is inherently limiting. Genuine agency encompasses the power to shape, govern and contest digital systems.

How we understand this capacity depends on the angle from which we seek to exercise it. From the standpoint of digital infrastructure, it means the ability to build, adapt, and govern digital architectures. At the data level is refers to active participation on how data is encoded, represented and repurposed into knowledge. At the governance level, effective participation spans a broader spectrum – influencing how systems and data are used, their purposes and benefits, and sustaining that decision-making power throughout the entire data lifecycle.

From this perspective, cultural integrity acquires a vital dimension of agency. Beyond preserving traditions, knowledge, or identities in the face of digitization, we must retain and exercise the capacity for self-determination throughout the process itself. Ultimately, we must ask ourselves, what kind of data-relational society do we truly want to build? One that expands the exercise of our rights into the digital realm, or one that ends up restricting and conditioning them?

Shaping our digital future: Conclusions

Human rights stem from the recognition of human dignity and autonomy. In increasingly datafied societies, self-determination acquired renewed urgency. As individuals and part of communities we must retain the capacity to shape our lives, identities and futures within the digital realm.

Digital self-determination encompasses both individual and a collective dimension. Much like physical reality, the digital experience has a singular dimension while also embedding collective decisions, shared knowledge, cultural identities and common interests. These interconnected dimensions are especially critical for vulnerable and marginalized communities facing the asymmetries of the digital world—particularly when entering digital spaces under unequal conditions.

This framework requires projecting our capacity to respect, integrate and realize rights, interests and expectations within digital ecosystems, ensuring that participation is mutually beneficial for all involved and extends across the entire data lifecycle.

As human existence becomes continuously datafied, the conditions governing fair digital participation concern us all – even as our starting points and exposure to systemic risks remain unequal. This reality should compel us to critically examine what truly means to build, exercise, and stand for self-determination within that digital age.

Artificial Intelligence tools were used to support preliminary literature identification, and information organization. The author reviewed and edited the output and takes full responsibility for the content of the publication.

References

Birhane, A. (2020). Algorithmic Colonization of Africa. SCRIPTed, 17(2)

Heeks, R. (2021). From Digital Divide to Digital Justice in the Global South: Conceptualising Adverse Digital Incorporation. Centre for Digital Development, University of Manchester. ssrn_id3907633_code1944854

Couldry N. & Mejias, U. (2018). Data Colonialism: Rethinking Big Data’s Relation to the Contemporary Subject. Television & New Media.

Verhulst, S. G. (2023). Operationalizing Digital Self-Determination. Data & Policy.

Taylor, L. (2017). What is Data Justice? The Case for Connecting Digital Rights and Freedoms Globally. Bid Data & Society.

Carroll, S. R. et al. (2020). The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance. Data Science Journal.

ITU (2025). Facts and Figures 2025. International Telecommunication Union.

ECLAC (2025). Digital Development Observatory: Internet Users. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean.

 

Agostina Coniglio. Lawyer (Pontifical Catholic University of Argentina). Master’s candidate in Environmental Law, Policy and Management (Austral University, Argentina). Co-founder of Keidos. Regional Board Member for Latin America at the Global Alliance of Impact Lawyers (GAIL). Professor at the Faculty of Law of the University of Buenos Aires and the Austral University.