Data governance is being written without the people who feed the world
69053
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-69053,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,wp-child-theme-WACC-bridge,bridge-core-3.3.5,qodef-qi--touch,qi-addons-for-elementor-1.11.2,qode-page-transition-enabled,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,qode-smooth-scroll-enabled,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-30.9.1,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,qode-wpml-enabled,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-9.0.1,vc_responsive,elementor-default,elementor-kit-41156

Data governance is being written without the people who feed the world

Soledad Vogliano

For food sovereignty movements, data justice means not only asking how data is governed, but in whose interests, under whose control, and with what consequences for peoples and the planet. It’s about power relations and building frameworks that strengthen human rights, cultural diversity, self-determination and community-driven innovation.

In the halls of national and multilateral decision-making, policymakers are scrambling to make sense of data governance. The growing spectre of AI is extending into every corner of our economies and politics, its so-called “inevitability” becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy as our governments compete to lay the tracks ahead of its advance. AI has added urgency to the task of policymaking on data governance, and history has shown that when policy is rushed, it is very often at the expense of justice.

In arenas where data governance policy is in development, like the UN Commission on Science and Technology for Development Data Governance Working Group, and sectoral spaces like the World Health Organisation, discussions focus on abstract understandings of privacy, access, interoperability or benefit-sharing. Of course, all of these aspects matter – but in the context of rapid datafication of our planet’s life-supporting systems, we must not get lost in these abstractions. We must remind ourselves that data governance must be framed in contextualized sectors and constituencies. For example, in rural development and food systems – where policy can impact up to 3.46 billion people worldwide – we must start at the beginning: with a shared understanding of how power and corporate interests are shaping this technological transformation.

Datafication of food systems

The datafication of food systems involves converting agricultural knowledge and resources into data assets, with the end goal of monitoring, tracking and optimizing those assets and production processes.1 One example of this is the quantification of soil – collecting soil samples and measuring the micronutrients, carbon, and moisture within, enabling the soil quality to be tracked digitally. Of course, there is profit to be made from this data – in the case of soil, for example, the data can be processed to generate targeted fertilizer recommendations.2

With this phenomenon comes a new wave of enclosure of what used to be common goods. Soil, seeds and the knowledge historically held, shared and adapted collectively across generations, are all being converted into proprietary data assets though different modes of datafication (for example, the digital sequencing of genetic information and digital satellite imagery).

A 2022 study estimated that in the years between 2004 and 2020, the volume of data generated per hectare of agricultural land soared, from just a few megabytes to 18 gigabytes. The study predicted that number would reach 40.5 gigabytes by 2025.3 In the short years since, the rapid growth of data sources on farms (sensors and digital devices, as well as satellites and drone technologies), and the exponential growth in demand for data with the advent of AI, has led to corporate controlled food systems being more data-driven than ever before.

Datafication provides further means for corporations to patent life – for example, seeds and genomes – and thus further entrench their control over global food systems. Data governance is where economics come into play – who decides what will be “datafied”, who controls the data, how it is processed, and commercialized.

1. Who is behind the massive drive for datafication within agricultural ecosystems? Who is developing the architecture of digitalization, and who benefits?

A powerful new alliance has taken hold of food systems: Big Ag firms have joined forces with Big Tech corporations like Google, Microsoft, Alibaba and Amazon to create cloud platforms and AI-driven decision tools. These tools and platforms are being integrated into all parts of industrial agriculture, from seeds to chemical inputs to machinery. Together with Big Ag, Big Tech is now shaping which technologies will be developed, informing decision-making, effectively shaping the future of farming.4

This advance comes at a moment when corporate concentration of industrial agribusiness is at an all-time high. A new report by ETC Group and GRAIN – Top Ten Agribusiness Giants – outlines how five out of six food sectors can already be considered oligopolies, leaving food systems ever more vulnerable to shocks caused by climate impacts and global instability.5

Now, those agribusiness giants are teaming up with the most powerful companies on Earth to harvest data and lock farmers into costly digital platforms. The drive for datafication in our food systems is not in the interests of food sovereignty, innovation, nor to improve the lives and livelihoods of those producing our food. It is all about expanding into new territories for profit. Farms are the next frontier in the push to commodify the commons and feed the insatiable appetite of data-hungry AI models.

2. Who decides what data is collected and what counts as useful knowledge? Who controls the infrastructures where data is stored and processed?

Peasants, Indigenous Peoples, pastoralists, fisherfolk, agricultural workers, women and rural communities ensure the nutrition of billions of people every day. They preserve and protect the nutritional, cultural and spiritual value of our seeds, crops, wild and farmed animals, as they have done for millennia, within models that respect planetary boundaries. These groups together produce 70% of the world’s food.6

These are the subjects of our food systems and at the heart of rural development policies – not simply “data providers” or “users” of digital tools. They are rights-holders, knowledge-holders and political actors. Their practices sustain food sovereignty and biodiversity and play a key role in building and preserving ecosystems resilience. The true extent of their contribution is beyond financial valuation.

They can all certainly benefit from access to technology and the use of data. However, in the digitalization architecture being constructed by Big Ag and Big Tech, they are not afforded the benefits of innovation. Instead, they are locked into dependency on subscription-based tools and platforms, while corporations encroach further into their territories.

For food sovereignty movements, data governance should support autonomy, not dependency. It should strengthen public and community-controlled infrastructures rather than deepen corporate concentration. It should promote frameworks for the commons and protect collective rights – including the rights of Indigenous Peoples and peasants.

This is not possible while the power imbalance between corporate giants and food producers goes unquestioned, and Big Ag and Big Tech are given free rein to shape the infrastructure of data collection, processing and use. Data justice requires us to return power and control of our food systems to those who generate it.

3. Who pays the price?

AI is rapidly reorganizing what production looks like all over the world. It is reshaping our economies and global value chains. In the midst of this transformation, a new, yet familiar, order is emerging.

Governments, Big Tech and Big Ag corporations in the Global North are harvesting the value of data (assets, products, innovation patents) created by the low-paid labour and resources of those in the Global South. At the same time, those in the South are overwhelmingly forced to bear the environmental and social costs of critical mineral mining and AI infrastructure. Food sovereignty and data justice movements, particularly in Africa and other parts of the Global South are highlighting the “unbroken line” between colonialism and digital colonialism.7 The deep asymmetries in digital infrastructure, capital, and bargaining power mean that countries are embarking upon digitalization and datafication from wildly different starting points. This global reality must be recognized amid the urgency to design national and international data governance policies.8

Conclusion

Data justice is not an add-on; it is a precondition for a genuinely people-centred development paradigm. It requires collective sovereignty over both data and mineral resources, paired with regenerative, non-extractive technological approaches – in this way, it is inseparable from environmental justice and human rights. Opposite to the abstract approaches of the data governance policy debates, an original data justice lens must be grounded in the lived experiences and livelihoods of food producers.

Rather than focusing on how to make data flow more efficiently, a data justice approach would interrogate whether certain data should be collected, shared or commercialized at all. This question seems to have been left in the dust far behind us, outpaced by the false urgency and inevitability narrative that propels the vehicle of AI adoption. It is our task to force a pause and pose this question to those who are accountable.

Global South peoples want to share equitably in the benefits of innovation, but not at the cost of allowing extractive data practices. Without an actionable data justice framework, new technologies like AI will follow the blueprint of colonial extractivism. By embedding the principle of data justice in multilateral spaces – in arenas that are drawing up rural development and food systems policies that will impact billions of people worldwide – we can protect the web of life while improving the lives and livelihoods of people across the planet.

This article is based on an intervention at the session “Putting data justice at the heart of AI governance” organized by IT For Change at the World Summit on the Information Society 2026.

Notes

1. Samon, K. (2020). Defending Food Sovereignty in the Data Economy. Bot Populi. https://botpopuli.net/video/defending-food-sovereignty-in-the-data-economy/

2. Canfield, M., Masinjila, S., Ntambirweki, B. (2025). What does data justice mean for African small-holder farmers? Towards envisioning a human rights-based approach in Africa. Agroecology Now. https://agroecologynow.net/what-does-data-justice-mean-for-african-small-holder-farmers-towards-envisioning-a-human-rights-based-approach-in-africa/

3. Kayad, A., Sozzi, M., Paraforos, D. S., Rodrigues, F. A., Cohen, Y., Fountas, S., Francisco, M.J., Pezzuolo, A., Grigolato, S., & Marinello, F. (2022). How many gigabytes per hectare are available in the digital agriculture era? A digitization footprint estimation. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 198, Article 107080. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compag.2022.107080

4. IPES-Food (2026). Head in the Cloud: Challenging the false promise of digital agriculture and cultivating innovation from the ground up, https://ipes-food.org/. https://ipes-food.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/HeadInTheCloud.pdf

5. ETC Group, GRAIN (2026). Top 10 Agribusiness Giants: Corporate concentration in food & farming – 2026 update. https://www.etcgroup.org/sites/www.etcgroup.org/files/files/top_10_2026_en.pdf

6. ETC Group (2022). Small Scale Farmers and Peasants Still Feed the World. https://www.etcgroup.org/sites/www.etcgroup.org/files/files/31-01-2022_small-scale_farmers_and_peasants_still_feed_the_world.pdf

7. Mwema, E. (2026). AI, Digitalization & Environmental Justice – Mapping the Context of Zambia and its Neighbours. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nNZ-UHUZFPNgTAqJn9sVB-Lc_jaa072K/view

8. IT for Change (2026). Putting Data Justice at the Heart of AI Governance. Session Outcome Document. https://www.itu.int/net4/wsis/forum/2026/Agenda/Session/385

 

Soledad Vogliano is a senior campaigner and researcher with ETC Group, who is currently investigating and promoting the debate on the impacts of the digitization of food systems