Development and the AI fallacy
69044
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-69044,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,wp-child-theme-WACC-bridge,bridge-core-3.3.5,qodef-qi--touch,qi-addons-for-elementor-1.11.2,qode-page-transition-enabled,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,qode-smooth-scroll-enabled,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-30.9.1,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,qode-wpml-enabled,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-9.0.1,vc_responsive,elementor-default,elementor-kit-41156

Development and the AI fallacy

Thobekile Matimbe

The current euphoria over AI adoption and deployment in Zimbabwe presents a particular impression of artificial intelligence (AI) being the long-awaited antidote to the country’s development problems, escalating it towards its Sustainable Development Goals. Zimbabwe’s National AI Strategy – launched in March 2026 – echoes a strong mantra of AI for Development, with the call for all entrepreneurs to rally behind the great vision. This is progressive towards increasing innovation and ensuring that the national AI strategy is locally supported by various stakeholders.

The AI strategy echoes among others “meaningful opportunities for all Zimbabweans, particularly marginalized communities, rural populations, women, youth and people with disabilities” ensuring equal access to AI education (Pillar 1) and distributed infrastructure reducing digital divides (Pillar 2), sector-specific applications prioritizing underserved populations (Pillar 3) and community-level governance structures with Ubuntu-centred ethics (Pillar 4). These are great aspirations that are reflected in policy yet lived experiences still raise concerns.

There are currently inadequate steps towards bridging digital literacy gaps to ensure the technological revolution does not leave anyone behind and this requires clear metrics, an implementation plan and follow through. The vision for development is every African country’s dream, but development for whom? Various critical sectors, such as health, education and agriculture, are seen as requiring the magic AI wand that will change livelihoods for the greater good. Fact or fiction?

That is the million-dollar question, as the greater part of the country’s rural population is digitally excluded. While benefits exist, a simple litmus test is a valid question. Does a child using AI-powered education technologies in a public school in the capital city of Zimbabwe, Harare, have the same access to education as a child in a remote rural town where access to data, broadband access and digital devices are not easily accessible, afforded or understood to be a necessity by the community existing to find their next meal. If the answer is no, then AI has a long way to go before it can catapult the country into an economic boom.

What is missing?

Undeniably, as highlighted by the Preliminary Report of the Independent International Scientific Panel on AI, this emerging technology is transformative, with evidence-backed gains across the identified sectors, yet conditional, as they depend on local context, adequate infrastructure, and human preparedness. The context element is part of the puzzle to solving the country’s developmental impasse and it starts with an acknowledgement of the digital divide’s extent, an assessment of who would be left behind and robust strategies to include them so that an informed agricultural sector would benefit, for instance, from predictive capabilities of AI improving the ability of farmers to increase their harvest, strengthening food security while the benefits for education are leveraged from private schools to the government schools in the most remote parts of the country.

This prompts reflection on the gaps that exist not just because of uneven AI use but also because of the technological environment in which it is being adopted. The fault line runs deep beyond the emerging technology itself that has seen benefits on one hand and adverse harm on the other.

This Southern African country has its fair share of challenges, not only in connectivity but also in digital literacy and digital access. Datareportal presents that in 2026, Zimbabwe had a population of 17.0 million. Approximately 60% of Zimbabwe’s population is in the rural areas, according to the 2025 Report by the World Bank. From Datareportal, there were 6.54 million individuals using the internet in Zimbabwe at the end of 2025, when online penetration stood at 38.4%. To this end, aspects of connectivity, digital access, and literacy remain critical gaps that constrain the inclusive adoption of AI.

Areas of concern

Information ecosystem threats exist that can be cured by digital literary especially as the buzzing age of AI promises more sophisticated harm as seen through deepfakes. However, the government has adopted various legislative measures to address information disorders, with areas of misalignment with human rights especially where they criminalise false news or have overly broad sanctions. Media workers, for instance, have been arrested on the strength of false criminalisation of false news based on the country’s Criminal Code and the Cyber and Data Protection Act, 2021, approaches that are contrary to international human rights standards. Yet, misinformation, disinformation and other harmful speech remain a threat to information integrity regardless and require a more proactive approach of digital literacy.

While the government has taken commendable strides to develop a National AI Strategy, this policy grandstanding raises eyebrows from a practical digital inclusion lens. With such governmental optimism about the technology’s potential to improve various sectors in the country, the other side of the coin is the potential exclusion and harm arising from AI deployment, which is seemingly obscured by the AI buzz. According to the United Nations, without swift action and guardrails, AI risks accelerating the breakdown of the integrity of the information ecosystem.

This is aptly put and, critically, can be addressed by digital literacy on the responsible use of AI in communities. Synthetic media has great potential for harm, with the need for capacity building on ethical content creation in the information ecosystem. The rise of AI-generated content is threatening the legitimacy of independent journalism, and this is an area where a forward-looking AI strategy can prioritise, to ensure human rights are preserved through measurable community sensitisation approaches.

The African Union Continental AI Strategy has identified critical structural risks including a gender digital divide and articulates clearly that “disparities in digital literacy and access to AI technologies could deepen existing inequalities between men and women, affect already unconnected people, limit opportunities for some populations, and hinder Africa’s competitiveness in the global AI landscape.” This assessment is a fair presentation of Zimbabwe’s operating context, which would require a precise approach to ensure AI adoption yields inclusive results.

In order to address the digital divide, Paradigm Initiative’s Londa 2025 Report on the state of digital rights and inclusion in Africa assesses the utilisation of universal service funds (USF) in Africa, with a specific recommendation for the Postal & Telecommunications Regulatory Authority of Zimbabwe (POTRAZ) to proactively disclose information on its USF. The current opacity on the utilisation of the funds does not demonstrate accountability.

About rights or nothing at all

Paradigm Initiative’s Global South Primer titled What’s the Whole Fuss About AI elaborately states that “access, affordability skills and agency must work together.” Without this marriage of approaches, broadband and data access alone still leave vast populations at the peripheries of the benefits that are yet to become a reality. In this primer, the concept of human dignity is positioned as central to Ubuntu and no doubt, a human rights imperative and not a Western notion. To this end, the human dignity of communities who are excluded from the conversations on AI is imperilled when policymaking processes exclude them from the tables of AI governance.

Reimagining life beyond the adoption of the national AI strategy, the proof is in the pudding. Beyond the hype that the policy exists for development, what key steps will be taken to ensure that development is attained in critical socio-economic sectors such as education, labour and health? These are some of the most pressing needs for the most vulnerable. How does AI benefit them? For Zimbabwe, digital inclusion more broadly and basically, before AI inclusion, is a primary necessity towards the equal realisation of basic human rights.

Promoting community solutions

The Zimbabwean AI Strategy posits an Ubuntu-based, multi-level governance system with robust legislation, ethical safeguards and leadership in responsible AI. In keeping with the spirit of digital ubuntu, the communitarian approach is not exclusionary but inclusionary, where communities thrive together, not as a single unit. In order to thrive in the AI era, community-centred connectivity approaches should be supported through responsive budgetary allocations with easy access to digital devices for the underserved communities and affordable internet access. The strategy clearly focuses heavily on addressing digital divides by largely increasing broadband and data access. While these are critical components, broadband access without digital devices is an abstract approach to addressing digital gaps in the country. Moreso, without deliberate and measurable digital literacy approaches, AI harms can thrive such as information disorders.

The World Summit on Information Society (WSIS+20) Outcome Document, adopted in December 2025, highlights that to achieve accessible and affordable broadband subscription costs, there is a need for collaboration among all stakeholders, utilizing universal service funds and community networks. Recognised approaches are key, such as ensuring that schools, post offices, libraries and hospitals are equipped to meet not just a connectivity needs but, holistically, access to digital devices and digital literacy as a necessity for those in underserved communities. With inclusive, digital Ubuntu approaches, a national strategy can be truly meaningful for those often left behind as the technology adoption blitzkrieg progresses like a runaway train. This is one sure way of addressing information integrity, when skills to use technology are well imparted.

Turning to the imperatives

The United Nations highlights that “underserved groups need equal access to digital opportunities and that digital divides reflect and amplify existing social, cultural and economic inequalities.” This means that when adopting a technology, it should be accompanied by a robust human rights impact assessment that fully grasps the extent of the exclusion in order to better tackle it. While the benefits of AI can bring development to various sectors, the lived reality of digitally excluded groups and communities in Zimbabwe’s society cannot be overlooked.

To move towards development and away from mere promises is to see digital inclusion as a human rights priority, reinforcing the right to human dignity, equality for all and guarding against disintegrating social cohesion in the information ecosystem. In order to have a holistic and well-rounded approach, digital divides are solved by multiple approaches with clear metrics. Financing is a critical aspect of that approach and requires national budgets to align and support implementation while various stakeholders ensure they collaborate with the government to dismantle the current abstract vision of development, making it a reality. To this end, the government must take clear pathways to operationalise the ambitious national AI strategy.

To transform a fallacy into reality, first, a robust human rights impact assessment is needed to address equality in digital access; second, commitment towards enabling access to digital devices; third, a measurable action plan to increase digital literacy with clear targets; fourth, leveraging diverse stakeholders including the private sector, media, civil society actors as partners in addressing the digital divide; fifth ensuring that human rights are protected as AI uptake increases; and lastly enhancing connectivity through broadband access enables a better digital future for AI adoption.

References

Zimbabwe’s National AI Strategy https://veritaszim.net/sites/veritas_d/files/Zimbabwe%20National%20Artificial%20Intelligence%20Strategy.pdf

Preliminary Report of the Independent International Scientific Panel on AI https://www.un.org/independent-international-scientific-panel-ai/en/preliminary-report

Zimbabwe Unveils 2026–2030 AI Strategy to Advance Inclusive Digital Transformation https://zimbabwe.un.org/en/311859-zimbabwe-unveils-2026%E2%80%932030-ai-strategy-advance-inclusive-digital-transformation

World Bank https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.RUR.TOTL.ZS?locations=ZW

The State of Digital in Zimbabwe https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2026-zimbabwe

Londa 2025 https://paradigmhq.org/londa-25/

WSIS+20 Outcome Document https://docs.un.org/en/A/RES/80/173

What’s the Whole Fuss About AI https://paradigmhq.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Whats-the-Whole-Fuss-About-AI_-A-Global-South-Primer.pdf?x87894

 

Thobekile Matimbe is Senior Manager Partnerships and Engagements at Paradigm Initiative, Bulawayo, Zimbabwe.