The breath that gives life to culture: Why digital justice needs communication justice
69032
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-69032,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,wp-child-theme-WACC-bridge,bridge-core-3.3.5,qodef-qi--no-touch,qi-addons-for-elementor-1.11.2,qode-page-transition-enabled,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,qode-smooth-scroll-enabled,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-30.9.1,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,qode-wpml-enabled,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-9.0.1,vc_responsive,elementor-default,elementor-kit-41156

The breath that gives life to culture: Why digital justice needs communication justice

Kersti Ruth Wissenbach

In September 2024, the United Nations adopted the Global Digital Compact (GDC), its most comprehensive framework to date for governing the digital future. The document calls for ensuring that digital technologies and AI are used responsibly and benefit all, addressing the digital divide and fostering a safe and inclusive digital environment. It is a significant commitment. It is also, in important ways, a familiar one, and this familiarity is part of the problem.

For decades, the dominant framing of digital governance has been organised around access, safety, and inclusion. More connectivity, better regulation, safer environments. These are real and pressing concerns, but they consistently leave the architecture of digital systems intact and ask communities to adapt to a world as it has been designed rather than shape it according to their own needs, values, and knowledge systems. As the Association for Progressive Communications underlined in its contribution to the WSIS+20 review process, the emphasis needs to be on harnessing of digital tools to support people-centred development rather than the development of digital tools and processes (APC, 2026). The distinction matters but has been consistently blurred.

This article argues that the infrastructure bias in dominant digital governance discourse has a history, and that recovering that history, with specific attention to the MacBride Commission’s 1980 report Many Voices, One World and the decades-long struggle for the right to communicate it represented, is both a political and analytical necessity. It re-attributes argument for a communication versus information framework as a digital justice requirement. Its absence from current digital governance forums risks sustaining a tech-solutionist bias that prevents digital justice from becoming what it should be: an expression of cultural justice grounded in communication justice.

Cultural justice is communication justice

Communication, unlike the causal character of information, seeks to produce reciprocity, shared decisions, unprogrammed response, intrinsically binding it to the essence of community and human relations (Pasquali, 1963). Assessing digital justice through a communication justice lens therefore requires asking what model of human relations a given infrastructure, and its governing frameworks, tends to support. This distinction has been consistently submerged in digital policy discourse, where the terms communication and information are used interchangeably in ways that privilege the latter since communication processes have historically been viewed as separate from the devices or methods people use (Lievrouw, 2011). The result is what might be called a disproportionate media-as-infrastructure perspective that evaluates digital systems by what they transmit rather than by the quality of relations from which they emerge or which they foster.

Justice therefore requires attention to human relations1 as the ground from which transformation must grow. Culture does not emerge from access to tools, content, or platforms, but from people being in active relation with and within reality, through what Freire called acts of creation, re-creation, and decision. Where communication is understood as dialogue, a relational act oriented towards mutual awareness, reflection, and action, it becomes the breath that gives life to culture (Freire, 1970). Without such dialogue, participation gives way to what he called cultural silencing: communities whose voices are not absent but suppressed, not voiceless but silenced (Freire, 1979). Cultural justice and communication justice are therefore intrinsically intertwined, making communication justice a foundation of digital justice.

Digital justice and the priority of human relations

Today’s digital landscape reproduces structural parallels with the media order of the past: dominated by a small number of platform corporations whose algorithmic systems encode particular languages, epistemologies, and models of human relations as defaults. The shift from broadcasting monopolies to algorithmic control, data extraction, and AI-mediated knowledge systems has created new forms of silencing. The distinction between not having a voice and voices being silenced matters because it shifts the question from how to include people in systems designed elsewhere to what conditions are necessary for people to be authors of the systems through which they communicate.

What is required is an ontological shift, from media and digital infrastructure to human relational needs as the given from which analysis and policy must depart. Technology serves cultural justice only where it responds to the communicative needs of specific communities and ecosystems in their contexts. Digital justice cannot be achieved through infrastructural logic alone but requires infrastructure to become subordinate to cultural integrity. Communication justice, understood as the capacity to speak in one’s own language, express one’s perspectives, and exercise genuine democratic agency in shaping and governing communication infrastructures as shared commons, must thus become a driving force of digital governance.

Applied to digital systems, this means asking not only whether communities have connectivity but whether the systems through which they communicate enable reciprocity, shared decision-making, and cultural self-determination, or reproduce dependencies and exclusions that characterised the global media order. The answer, in the current moment of platform capitalism and AI-driven knowledge systems, is largely the latter.

The representation of only a handful of the 7,613 documented languages in major AI systems, for example, does not simply indicate a connectivity gap but demonstrates the structural exclusion of cultural diversity at a scale and speed unprecedented in the history of communication (UNESCO, 2025). This echoes the structural logic that the International Commission for the Study of Communication Problems identified in the MacBride Report, in a different technological context, in 1980 (Mansell and Nordenstreng, 2006; UNESCO, 1980). Closing the connectivity gap while leaving the epistemic gap intact simply gives more people access to a system that does not challenge agency and ownership structures.

Many Voices, One World: arguments that have not expired

The MacBride Report is remembered, where it is remembered at all, as a document of its time, an episode in a Cold War-era political battle over media ownership and information flows that ended badly when the United States and United Kingdom withdrew from UNESCO in 1984 and 1985. Whilst this reading is accurate as history, it is misleading as analysis. The core arguments of Many Voices, One World have not expired but have been repeatedly vindicated by the very technological transformations that were supposed to make them obsolete. Its early warning against the disproportionate emphasis on technological advances at the expense of the critical roles of meaning-making and cultural justice has not found equal attention since, not even in the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) process, whose targets remain heavily focused on technology (Mansell and Nordenstreng, 2006).

The MacBride Commission’s foundational argument was that communication is a human right, not a commodity to be distributed according to purchasing power or geopolitical influence, but a condition of human dignity and cultural agency. This distinction between communication as right and communication as service or infrastructure is precisely the one that the GDC fails to make. By framing digital justice primarily as a question of responsible use and equitable access, it positions communication systems as neutral utilities to be distributed more fairly, rather than as political and cultural architectures whose design embodies particular power relations and whose governance determines whose cultures, languages, and knowledge systems are sustained or erased.

The Commission went further. It distinguished between access to communication and the right to communicate, which includes the right to produce, transmit, and govern communication on one’s own terms. This implies that communities must be authors, builders, and decisionmakers of the systems that carry their voices, not passive recipients of systems designed for them by others. Cultural integrity, understood as the capacity of communities to sustain and develop their own cultural forms, languages, and knowledge systems, is not an aspiration to be added onto digital inclusion strategies but constitutes the precondition of genuine communication justice, and therefore of genuine digital justice.

The Commission also made a structural critique that remains essential. Global communication inequality is not only the product of insufficient infrastructure investment. It is produced by the concentration of ownership and control over communication systems in the hands of a minority of actors whose interests are neither plural nor local. In 1980, this meant Western broadcasting corporations and news agencies. Although the report has been critiqued for not sufficiently recognising that the New World Information and Communication Order (NWICO) would likely be the order of transnational cooperation (Hamelink, 1980), its structural concerns are visible today in a handful of platform corporations and AI developers shaping the epistemic landscape from the outside in. Whilst the mechanisms have changed, the structure has not.

The MacBride Report was a historic milestone precisely because it articulated the structural conditions of communication inequality rather than treating them as technical problems with technical solutions (Nordenstreng, 2010). The agenda for a NWICO that it proposed was not, at its core, a demand for more infrastructure but a demand for democratic governance of communication systems, for what would now be called communication sovereignty. That demand has been progressively stripped from digital governance discourse as the infrastructure logic has reasserted itself, first through the WSIS process and now through the GDC.

The infrastructure logic and the memory it suppresses

The transition from the NWICO debates of the 1980s to the digital governance forums of today has been accompanied by a systematic forgetting of the communication rights framework those debates produced. As Hamelink (2015) has argued, the question for digital governance is not whether we are building an information society but whether we are building a communication society, one in which the conditions for genuine dialogue, cultural self-determination, and democratic participation in the governance of communication systems are actively cultivated. This includes the urgent question of civic ownership through a commons lens, which has been consistently displaced by the more tractable question of how to extend access to systems. The analytical frameworks shaping digital governance discourse have consistently fallen short of providing the conceptual grounds for a genuine communication justice approach.

This is not only a political failure but also an intellectual one, rooted in the disciplinary separation between communication studies and the fields that dominate digital governance debates. Despite the cultural turn in the social sciences, the field of social movement studies, and its media practice work rooted in media studies, has struggled to fully embrace the distinction between communication as a relational practice and communication as a mediated infrastructure. The gap has limited its capacity to contribute a communication justice framework to digital governance debates (Wissenbach, 2019). The data justice discourse offers a route back to participatory traditions by situating data within broader social and economic justice claims. Whilst the structural move echoes what a communication justice framework would need to make against digital governance’s infrastructure logic, it is also departs from the data lifecycle (Dencik et al. 2016, 2019). The strongest echo of communication tradition emphasises that justice claims must be grounded in situated, not universal, standpoints (Milan and Treré, 2019).

What the MacBride framework requires of digital justice today

If the intrinsic connection between communication justice and cultural justice is taken seriously as the foundation of digital justice, several things follow.

Community-centred communication infrastructures, including community internet networks, locally owned mobile operators, community media organisations, and community data initiatives that keep governance in local hands are models of what democratic communication infrastructure looks like when it is designed from the inside out. The MacBride Commission’s call for strengthening national and local media capacity to avoid dependency on external sources remains as relevant for community infrastructure initiatives today as it was for community radio in 1980. These initiatives require systematic investment and policy frameworks that treat communication sovereignty as a legitimate governance goal.

The question of epistemic and linguistic justice in AI is an urgent contemporary expression of the MacBride agenda. The encoding of particular knowledge systems and languages into AI models at the expense of others is not a technical oversight to be addressed through diversity initiatives. It is a structural reproduction of the epistemic exclusion the Commission diagnosed, the silencing of cultural forms that do not conform to the dominant communication order. Advocacy entry points exist at the GDC follow-up, the Internet Governance Forum (IGF), and WSIS processes, but they require a communication rights framing that connects AI governance to the longer history of the struggle for cultural self-determination, rather than treating it as a novel problem generated by new technology.

Lastly, it requires a shift in how the success of digital justice initiatives is evaluated. The question of success must be defined by communities themselves, by what they identify as enabling genuine communication and cultural expression on their own terms, rather than by funders’ metrics or political agendas that measure connectivity, user numbers, or content volumes.

Conclusion

The argument of this article is not that technology is irrelevant to cultural or communication justice. It is that the intrinsic interrelation between communication justice and cultural justice must be re-centred if digital justice is to move beyond stagnant, infrastructure-led narratives. Revisiting the demands advanced by the MacBride Commission does not simply expose the structural amnesia of digital governance discourse; it brings a longstanding communication-rights framework back into current debates on digital and AI governance. The structural conditions of communication injustice have been known, named, and theorised for over four decades. What is missing is not the diagnosis, but its place in current governance responses.

The struggle for the right to communicate has been upheld since by communicators, activists, and scholars whose work provides an analytical framework for current digital justice debates. Recovering Many Voices, One World as a living resource for digital justice debates and reconnecting those debates with the communication rights scholarship that followed, is a political act. It matters as a way of challenging the tech-solutionist bias that continues to shape digital governance. It shifts the focus from communities as beneficiaries of digital inclusion to communities as authors of the communication systems through which they constitute their cultural lives.

Digital justice without communication justice is structurally incomplete. Communication justice, understood as the capacity of communities to speak in their own languages, from their own knowledge systems, within communication infrastructures they have a genuine role in shaping and governing, is the foundation from which digital justice must be built. The breath that gives life to culture is communication. That was the argument in 1980, and it remains the argument now.

Note

1. In fact, justice requires urgent attention to human and more-than-human relations. An ecological attention is urgent and addressed in other bodies of work. Due to the framework of the special issue, I will not elaborate this urgency and required pathways here.

References

APC. 2026. ‘Statement to the UN General Assembly WSIS+20 High-Level Meeting’. Media Development. https://waccglobal.org/statement-to-the-un-general-assembly-wsis20-high-level-meeting/

Dencik, Lina, Arne Hintz, and Jonathan Cable. 2016. ‘Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development’. Big Data & Society 3 (2). https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951716679678

Dencik, Lina, Arne Hintz, Joanna Redden, and Emiliano Treré. 2019. ‘Exploring Data Justice: Conceptions, Applications and Directions’. Information, Communication & Society 22 (7): 873–81. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369118X.2019.1606268

Freire, Paulo. 1970. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Herder and Herder.

Freire, Paulo. 1979. Cultural Action for Freedom. Harvard Educational Review.

Hamelink, Cees. 1980. Communication in the Eighties: A Reader on the ‘McBride Report’. IDOC International. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000042530

Hamelink, Cees. 2015. Global Communication. SAGE Publications Ltd. https://uk.sagepub.com/en-gb/eur/global-communication/book234369

Lievrouw, Leah. 2011. Alternative and Activist New Media – Digital Media and Society Series. Polity Press.

Mansell, Robin, and Kaarle Nordenstreng. 2006. ‘Great Media and Communication Debates: WSIS and the MacBride Report’. Information Technologies & International Development 3 (4): 15–36.

Milan, Stefania, and Emiliano Treré. 2019. ‘Big Data from the South(s): Beyond Data Universalism’. Television & New Media 20 (4): 319–35. https://doi.org/10.1177/1527476419837739

Nordenstreng, Kaarle. 2010. ‘MacBride Report as a Culmination of NWICO’. Les Enjeux de l’information et La Communication Supplement 2010-A. https://researchportal.tuni.fi/en/publications/macbride-report-as-a-culmination-of-nwico/

Pasquali, Antonio. 1963. Comunicación y Cultura de Masas. Monte Avila Editores, C.A.

UNESCO. 1980. Many Voices One World – Towards a New More Just and More Efficient World Information and Communication Order. UNESCO.

UNESCO. 2025. Global Roadmap for Multilingualism in the Digital Era: Advancing the Role of Language Technologies. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/ai-and-great-linguistic-flattening

Wissenbach, Kersti Ruth. 2019. ‘Accounting for Power in Transnational Civic Tech Activism: A Communication-Based Analytical Framework for Media Practice’. International Communication Gazette 82 (6): 545-563. https://doi.org/10.1177/1748048519832779

 

Kersti Ruth Wissenbach is a political sociologist and communication scientist with nearly twenty years of international experience at the intersection of digital transformation and social justice. As a senior policy adviser, research lead, strategy developer and educator, she has worked with activist groups, NGOs and public institutions across four continents. Combining academic and practitioner expertise, she has researched power dynamics in is negotiated through dialogue in transnational digital justice communities at the University of Amsterdam and the Centre on Social Movement Studies in Florence. Her recent work draws on permaculture to rethink digital justice as a regenerative, place-based practice. As founder and director of Spain-based Cultiva Lab, she brings participatory communication into dialogue with feminist ecology approaches, working with communities across and beyond Spain to foster climate resilience from the ground up.