Costa Rica: Freedom of expression and media pluralism
69060
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-69060,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,wp-child-theme-WACC-bridge,bridge-core-3.3.5,qodef-qi--no-touch,qi-addons-for-elementor-1.11.2,qode-page-transition-enabled,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-title-hidden,qode-smooth-scroll-enabled,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-30.9.1,qode-theme-bridge,qode_header_in_grid,qode-wpml-enabled,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-9.0.1,vc_responsive,elementor-default,elementor-kit-41156

Costa Rica: Freedom of expression and media pluralism

Vilma Peña-Vargas

Gretel Kahn’s recent report for the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, “Costa Rica used to be a beacon of press freedom in Central America. What changed?”, precisely documents a recent decline: in five years, Costa Rica fell from fifth to 38th place in Reporters Without Borders’ press freedom index, under the systematic harassment of Rodrigo Chaves’s government and now his successor Laura Fernández.

This is a real, documented fact, backed by testimony from Costa Rican editors and journalists, and it must be named unambiguously. But reducing the diagnosis to “a Chaves-style government attacking the press”–however true–leaves out the question that really matters: free to say what, and in whose voice?

Kahn’s report locates the rupture in 2022, with Chaves’s rise to power. And indeed, that is when a concrete offensive intensifies: the dismantling of state advertising budgets, tax persecution of media executives, visa revocations, and the building of troll networks financed or tolerated by those in power. All of this is documented and deserves the firmest condemnation.

The decline of Costa Rican media did not begin with Chaves. It has a longer history than this authoritarian episode acknowledges, and likely also responds to neoliberal trends running through the press worldwide: concentration of ownership, the collapse of the advertising model, and the precarious situation of newsrooms, among other features. Costa Rica is no exception to that global trend, but it isn’t explained by it alone.

Before Chaves, those same outlets – some rightly interviewed today as victims of authoritarian power – were not guarantors of pluralism but guardians of an order. A journalism built from the newsrooms of the country’s economic elites, with an agenda that rarely inconvenienced those who were, simultaneously, media owners and partners of traditional political and economic power. That is the genealogy the “beacon of press freedom” narrative omits: what was defended, almost always, was the interest of a handful of families and economic groups, not the collective right to communication.

What Costa Rican Chavismo threatens

The near-total absence of public and community media in Costa Rica is not a minor detail: it is structural. One can have formal press freedom – and Costa Rica does, with robust institutions and constitutional jurisprudence protecting it – while simultaneously sustaining a classist and patriarchal information ecosystem, where media pluralism never came to exist because its existence was limited. A hegemonic discourse does not need censorship to prevail: it only needs to be the sole voice with access to advertising, the agenda, and the microphone or camera.

What Costa Rican Chavismo threatens today, then, is not that nonexistent pluralism, but the symbolic monopoly of an elite that, until recently, alone decided what counted as news and who had the right to tell it. This is a shift of power within the elites, not a democratic opening of the media system. And that is why defending La Nación or CRHoy against presidential harassment – necessary and urgent as that is – is not the same as defending the country’s informational plurality. These are related battles, but they are not the same battle.

News without a subject

For twenty years, through the Global Media Monitoring Project (GMMP), promoted by WACC Global, we have documented another crisis–quieter and less visible in international indices: the systematic disappearance of people from the news, not only women, who are already significantly underrepresented. Fewer and fewer faces, fewer voices, fewer subjects speaking in the first person; more and more events narrated with no one inside them, where the news itself becomes its own protagonist. This is the progressive loss of investigative, critical, and educational journalism that builds citizenship, replaced by a description of facts stripped of the people who live them.

A news story without a subject is a news story without rights: neither the right of those at its centre to be presented with dignity, nor the collective right of all of society to communicate and to be heard.

The hopeful part: resilient media

There is a hopeful fact that deserves as much space as the denunciation. In Costa Rica, as elsewhere in Latin America, community media exist that fight to survive every day, with minimal resources and without the protection of a major capital-city newsroom, working to sustain their communities’ and territories’ right to communication. These are experiences that almost never appear in international indices or major reports, but that constitute the real foundation of the media pluralism the country lacks – and that awaits a state policy to guarantee the protection of its freedom to exist and to express itself.

That work matters because without the right to communication – the right of communities to name themselves, narrate themselves, and be heard on their own terms – no other right can be fully defended. There is no possible defense of health, land, water, air, gender equality, or justice if the possibility of speaking to them, and having those voices circulate, does not exist beforehand. There, in those persistent media outlets, lies the seed of a truly democratizing journalism: not one that resists from a position of privilege, but one that builds pluralism from diversity and territory.

Defending Costa Rican press against the authoritarianism of Chaves and Fernández is urgent, necessary, and right. But the freedom of expression worth defending with full force is not only that of a handful of historic newspapers now confronting the executive branch. It is that of an entire society – its children, its youth, its women, its rural communities, its community journalists – with the right to see themselves, hear themselves, and name themselves in their own media. That is the freedom of expression still to be built in Costa Rica, one that no international index fully measures.

 

Vilma Peña-Vargas is President of WACC’s Latin America Region. Educommunicator with academic background in Group Psychology and a Ph.D. in Education with a specialization in Pedagogical Mediation. Academic and liaison at the Office of Internationalization and Cooperation of the Distance State University (UNED), Costa Rica.