16 Nov 2017 Report urges media to change refugee narrative

A “pattern of invisibility” of refugees and migrants themselves can be found in news reports on asylum and migration in European media, according to a new report presented in Brussels on 16 November 2017.

Entitled, “Changing the Narrative: Media Representation of Refugees and Migrants in Europe”, the report is the result of a 12-month project – Refugee Reporting – coordinated by the World Association for Christian Communication – Europe region (WACC Europe) and the Churches’ Commission for Migrants in Europe (CCME).

Project findings, based on media monitoring in seven European countries – Greece, Italy, Spain, Serbia, the United Kingdom, Sweden and Norway – included that:

• Only 21% of news items on asylum and migration reference a refugee or migrant: This points to a pattern of invisibility that creates a clear divide between the policies being discussed at the political level and the effects of those policies on people.
• Certain groups of people are even more invisible: Women and some other groups of people are disproportionately absent from news articles about refugees and migrants.
• Of the 21% of the news items that referenced migrants or refugees, less than half (40%) of the articles quoted them directly: Direct quotes are the most accurate way to represent people, while inaccuracy of representation can easily lead to misunderstanding.
• Refugees and migrants are most often only identified by their “displacement”: When media do not go beyond the refugee label, and when the public tacitly accepts refugee as an occupation, people are deprived of their humanity and dignity.

“As organizations committed to communication rights and refugee rights, we believe that the voices of refugees and migrants themselves need to be heard in the media to better inform the public debate,” WACC Europe president, Stephen Brown, and CCME general secretary, Doris Peschke, write in a foreword to the report. “WACC Europe and CCME believe that the representation of refugees and migrants in the media both reflect and contribute to public attitudes.”

The report goes on to make recommendations for media professionals and news organisations; refugee-led organisations and groups; and civil society organisations working with refugees and migrants.

For media, these include:

• Adhering to the five core principles of ethical journalism: accuracy, independence, impartiality, humanity and accountability.
• Including more individual refugees and migrants in stories on refugee and migration issues, and use more direct quotes from refugees and migrants.
• Including refugees and migrants in news reports as experts.
• Fostering links and mutual capacity building with refugee networks and groups.
• Seeking increased diversity, including more people with a refugee or migrant background, in newsrooms and on editorial teams.

Recommendations for refugee-led organisations and groups include identifying journalists at local and national level who work on migration and asylum issues and reach out to them to develop a relationship; and understanding the needs of media in order to be able to present stories most effectively and in a way that enables media to make the best use of them.

As well as media monitoring in the seven European countries, interviews were conducted with representatives of refugee networks and media, including a consultation bringing people from both groups together to review the initial research findings.

A summary of the report and its recommendations is available here. También en español aquí. Full report available here.

The project was made possible with financial support from the Otto per Mille (OPM) fund of the Waldensian Church in Italy. Additional financial support came from the Evangelical Church in the Rhineland, Germany, the World Council of Churches, and CCME, in collaboration with the Conference of European Churches and WACC Global.

For more information, please contact: Sara Speicher or Torsten Moritz

Photo above: Cover image for the report “Changing the Narrative: Media Representation of Refugees and Migrants in Europe.”